← Go back to Life & Times

Ultrasociality

Eusociality is a fascinating and complex form of social organization that's observed in some animal species, most notably among insects like bees, ants, and termites, but also in some crustaceans and mammals (like the naked mole-rat). It's characterized by three main features:

  1. Cooperative Brood Care: This includes the communal care of offspring that aren't directly one's own, ensuring the survival and success of the colony's young. It's not just about parents caring for their offspring but the entire community contributing to the upbringing of the next generation.
  2. Reproductive Division of Labor: In eusocial societies, not all members reproduce. Typically, there are one or more individuals who are responsible for reproducing (queens in bees and ants, for example), while the majority of the colony is made up of non-reproductive individuals (workers, soldiers) that perform the necessary tasks to maintain and protect the colony.
  3. Overlap of Generations: Eusocial societies have overlapping generations that cooperate in the care of the young. This means that offspring assist in raising their siblings, creating a continuous cycle of care and cooperation.

The evolution of eusociality is a significant topic in evolutionary biology because it seems to challenge the basic principle of Darwinian evolution, which centers on individual survival and reproduction. The concept of "inclusive fitness" and the gene-centered view of evolution, notably promoted by biologists like W.D. Hamilton and Richard Dawkins, help explain eusociality. They suggest that helping relatives can indirectly pass on your genes, even if you don't reproduce directly, because relatives share a significant proportion of your genes. Eusociality allows for complex and highly efficient societies, with individuals specializing in particular tasks (such as foraging, nest maintenance, or defense), leading to highly organized and resilient communities. This specialization and division of labor contribute to the ecological success of eusocial species, allowing them to become dominant forces in their environments. The study of eusociality not only sheds light on the diversity of social organization in the animal kingdom but also provides insights into the evolutionary dynamics of cooperation, altruism, and social complexity. It's a clear demonstration of how evolutionary pressures can lead to the development of cooperative behaviors and complex social systems, even among organisms with relatively simple cognitive capacities.

Humans aren't typically classified as eusocial in the strict biological sense that applies to species like ants, bees, and termites. The definition of eusociality involves specific criteria, such as reproductive division of labor, cooperative brood care, and overlapping generations working together in a communal living situation. While humans exhibit some characteristics that are similar to eusocial behavior, especially in terms of cooperative care of offspring and complex social structures, there are key differences:

  1. Reproductive Division of Labor: Unlike eusocial species where only certain individuals have the reproductive role (like queen bees or ants), in human societies, reproductive capabilities are not limited to specific individuals. Virtually all humans are biologically capable of reproducing, and there isn't a strict division where only certain individuals are tasked with reproduction while others are permanently non-reproductive.
  2. Overlapping Generations: Humans do live in overlapping generations and often work together across generations for the welfare of the group, which does align somewhat with eusocial characteristics. However, this trait is not unique to eusocial species and is common in many social animals.
  3. Cooperative Brood Care: Humans definitely exhibit cooperative care for their young, with extended families and even broader communities often taking part in raising children. This aspect is somewhat eusocial in nature but again, not unique to eusociality.

However, some researchers have argued for a broader definition of eusociality or have suggested that human social organization has parallels with eusociality, especially when considering the complex social structures and cooperative behaviors seen in human societies. The concept of "ultrasociality" has been proposed to describe the human capacity for large-scale cooperation and complex societal structures, which includes the ability to form large, cooperative groups beyond immediate family ties, driven by cultural evolution and social constructs.

In summary, while humans share some characteristics with eusocial species, such as cooperative breeding and complex social organization, they do not fit the strict biological definition of eusociality. Instead, humans represent a unique form of social complexity that's influenced by both biological and cultural evolution, highlighting the diversity of social structures in the animal kingdom.

Eusocial species like ants, bees, and termites have developed fascinating and efficient ways to communicate and share information, which are crucial for the survival and functioning of their highly organized societies. These communication methods are primarily non-verbal and rely on chemical signals, physical contact, and other sensory cues. Here's how they compare to human communication:

Ants

  • Chemical Signals (Pheromones): Ants are perhaps most famous for their use of pheromones, chemical signals that can convey a wide range of information such as alarms, food trails, and colony identification. For example, when a forager ant finds food, it releases a trail pheromone back to the colony, which other ants follow to the food source.
  • Tactile Communication: Ants also use touch, such as antennal contact, to share information about their needs, roles, or the state of the colony.

Bees

  • Waggle Dance: Honeybees are renowned for their "waggle dance," a remarkable behavior where a bee communicates the location of food sources relative to the sun and the hive by performing a series of movements in a figure-eight pattern. The angle and duration of the dance convey information about the direction and distance of the food source.
  • Pheromones: Bees also use pheromones for various purposes, including marking flowers they've visited, signaling distress, and regulating colony activities.

Termites

  • Pheromones: Similar to ants and bees, termites rely heavily on chemical communication through pheromones for colony coordination, mating, and alarm signaling.
  • Vibrations: Termites can also communicate through vibrations. For instance, when a threat is detected, some species will bang their heads against the walls of their tunnels to create vibrations that warn the colony of danger.

Humans

  • Verbal Communication: Humans primarily use complex verbal language, which allows for the conveyance of abstract ideas, emotions, intentions, and detailed information across vast distances and time. Language enables humans to build vast bodies of knowledge, culture, and technology.
  • Non-verbal Communication: This includes body language, facial expressions, gestures, and even the use of symbols and written language. Humans also utilize electronic communication and social media to share information globally and instantaneously.
  • Cultural Transmission: Beyond immediate communication, humans pass knowledge across generations through educational systems, literature, and now digital media, allowing for the accumulation and evolution of knowledge over time.

The comparison highlights a fundamental difference between the communication methods of eusocial species and humans. Eusocial species rely on direct, often non-verbal, cues that are instinctual and serve immediate needs related to survival and colony maintenance. In contrast, humans use complex language and technology for communication, which allows for the sharing of abstract concepts, cultural values, and knowledge accumulation over generations. This ability to communicate complex and abstract information is a key factor in the development and advancement of human societies.

all